Design of Automotive Towing DevicesGh.L. Mogan, I.D. Buzdugan — Transilvania University of Brașov
Worked exampleEx.3.3

Design of joint 1-4 (threaded joint) — example

Design data

Forces: FX = 1500 N, FY = 300 N, FZ = 700 N; transverse force Ft = 1530 N.

Operating constraints: temperature T = (−30…40) °C; outdoor working environment with high humidity.

Design constraints: type of fit of the threaded shank: clearance fit; fastening thread: metric; nut type: standard hexagon nut; flat washer; Grower spring washer.

Materials and heat treatments

Properties of the hook material (element 1)

MaterialHeat treatmentHardness [HB]Yield strengthUltimate tensile strength
C45 (0.45 % C)Quenching and high tempering280σ02 = 300 MPaσr = 600 MPa

Nut material: property class 6 (σr ≈ 600 MPa).

Contact properties of the materials

Since all the materials in contact are steels, the following are adopted: allowable steel-on-steel crushing stress σas = 70 MPa; steel-on-steel friction coefficients μ = 0.2, μ1 = 0.2, μ2 = 0.25.

Sizing and checking

Axial force in the bolt from the condition of transmitting Ft by friction: with Ft = 1530 N, βa = 1.2 and μ1 = 0.2 (the friction coefficient on the contact surface 1-4), Faș-t = 9180 N.

Total axial force in the threaded shank,

Faș = Faș-t + FZ = 9880 N.

Axial tightening force of the joint,

Fst = Faș-t = 9180 N.

From the tensile strength condition of the threaded shank, with Faș = 9880 N, β = 1.2, σat = σ02/c = (100…150) MPa (σat = 120 MPa is adopted), the required minor thread diameter is = 11.21 mm.

Adopted: metric thread M14 with p = 2 mm, d = 14 mm, d1 = 11.825 mm, d2 = 12.701 mm; clearance hole diameter D1 = 16 mm; M14 nut with m = 11 mm, S = 22 mm; flat washer with inner diameter d1 = 15 mm, outer diameter d2 = 24 mm and thickness h = 2.5 mm; Grower washer 14 with d1 = 14.2 mm, g = 3.2 mm.

From the crushing strength condition of the materials in contact, with the tightening force Fst = Faș-t = 9180 N, D1 = 16 mm, μ = 0.2 and σas = 70 MPa, the collar diameter is D2 = 20.6 mm (D2 = 21 mm is adopted).

From the screwing moment relation, with Fst = 9180 N, d2 = 12.701 mm, p = 2 mm, μ = 0.2 and α = 60°, Mî = 16577.2 Nmm.

From the pivoting moment relation, with Fst = 9180 N, μ1 = 0.2, S = 24 mm and D1 = 16 mm, Mp = 18604.8 Nmm.

Wrench torque: Mc = Mî + Mp = 35182 Nmm.

From the check of the threaded shank under combined loading (tension and torsion), with Faș = 9880 N, d1 = 11.825 mm and Mî = 16577.2 Nmm, σe = 136.1 MPa,

and σe ≤ σat: 136.1 ≤ max (100…150) MPa (satisfied).

From the self-locking check, with p = 2 mm, d2 = 12.701 mm, μ = 0.2 and α = 60°:

β2 = 2.87°, φ′ = 16.1°,

and β2 ≤ φ′: 2.87° ≤ 16.1° (satisfied).

Constructive-technological shapes

Towing hook, 1

Constructive-technological drawing

Adopted dimensions and technological parameters

– dimensions: Ds = 25 mm, D = 20 mm, l = 60 mm, Lc = 70 mm; l3 = 10 mm; D2 = 21 mm, d = 14 mm, l1 = 36 mm, l2 = 26 mm;

– transition zones are made with fillets: R1 = 2 mm, R2 = 2 mm, R3 = 0.5 mm;

– a protective chamfer, Chamfer2: 0.5×45°, and a technological chamfer, Chamfer1: 1.5×45°, are adopted;

– centre holes: A2.5/5.3;

– machining involves: turning, drilling, threading and grinding of the spherical surface;

– roughness of the spherical surface, finished by grinding: Ra1 = 3.2 µm; general surface roughness: Ra0 = 6.3 µm;

– since the element works in a corrosive environment, the spherical surface is protected by chrome plating to preserve its quality throughout the service life.

Upper tie rod, 4

Constructive-technological drawing

Adopted dimensions and technological parameters

– dimensions: b4 = 60 mm, h4 = 15 mm, R = 30 mm, L4 = 110 mm, D1 = 16 mm;

– protective chamfers of 0.5×45° are adopted on sharp edges;

– machining involves milling the end portions and drilling; the other surfaces remain unmachined, as indicated by the attached symbol;

– roughness of the machined surfaces: Ra1 = 12.5 µm; Ra2 = 6.3 µm.

Fasteners

Adopted dimensions

– nut: M10, d = 10 mm, S = 24 mm, m = 13 mm;

– flat washer: d1 = 15 mm, d2 = 24 mm, h = 2.5 mm;

– Grower spring washer: MN 14, d1 = 14.2 mm, g = 3.2 mm.