Design of Automotive Towing DevicesGh.L. Mogan, I.D. Buzdugan — Transilvania University of Brașov
Worked exampleEx.4.6

Checking elements 5, 6 and joint 5-6 (tube-in-tube) by FEA (ANSYS) — example

1. Analysis model and input data

Analysis model

Loading diagram (in the ATD coordinate system)

FEA model in ANSYS

Geometric parameters in ANSYS

Input data

Forces: FX = 1500 N, FY = 300 N, FZ = 700 N.

Moments: MX5 = 25500 Nmm, MY5 = 183500 Nmm, MZ5 = 24000 Nmm.

Geometric parameters: Z1 = 180 mm; h4 = 15 mm, L6 = 70 mm, h5 = 50 mm, t5 = 5 mm, h6 = 60 mm, t6 = 5 mm; h7 = 50 mm, x = 5 mm.

Material: S235, weldable general-purpose steel.

Operating constraints: temperature T = (−30…40) °C.

Parameters of the ANSYS model

Forces: Fx = FX = 1500 N, Fy = FY = 300 N, Fz = 0 (the force FZ is transmitted by the pin joint and is therefore not considered).

Moments: Mx = −MX5 = −25500 Nmm, My = MY5 = 183500 Nmm; Mz = MZ5 = 24000 Nmm.

Geometric parameters: He = 60 mm, Ve = 60 mm, H = 50 mm, V = 50 mm, Hi = 30 mm, Vi = 30 mm, H1 = 50 mm, V1 = 50 mm, L1 = 3 mm, L2 = 10 mm; FD1 = 40 mm and FD4 = 165 mm for Body1; FD1 = 35 mm for Body2.

Material: S235, weldable general-purpose steel, with σat = σ02/ca = 235/1.3 = 180 MPa (since the FEA model is more accurate, a lower allowable safety factor ca was adopted than for the classical, less accurate design models); allowable contact stresses: σas = 90 MPa, the allowable steel-on-steel normal crushing stress, and τas = 45 MPa, the allowable steel-on-steel tangential contact stress.

Viewing the support zone and the applied forces and moments

🖱

🖱

🖱

2. Results

Viewing the forces and moments in the reaction zone

🖱

🖱

Viewing the displacements

🖱

Viewing the stresses and pressures

Equivalent stresses in the global model (bodies 5 & 6)

🖱

Equivalent stresses in body (tube) 5

🖱

Equivalent stresses in body (tube) 6

🖱

Pressures on the contact surfaces

🖱

🖱

Tangential (friction) stresses on the contact surfaces

🖱

3. Checks

Deformation check

δ ≤ δa; 0.106 ≤ 5 mm (satisfied).

Note. The allowable deflection is set by the operating conditions.

Equivalent (von Mises) stress check

σech_max ≤ σat; 93.7 ≤ 180 MPa (satisfied),

where σech_max is the maximum equivalent stress in the figure above and σat the allowable tensile stress of the material of body (tube) 6.

Normal contact pressure check

pmax ≤ σas; 43.581 ≤ 90 MPa (satisfied),

where pmax is the maximum pressure in the figure above and σas the allowable crushing stress of the pair of materials.

Tangential contact stress check

τmax ≤ τas; 0.51 ≤ 45 MPa (satisfied),

where τmax is the maximum tangential contact stress (frictional stress) in the figure above and τas the allowable tangential contact stress.